Northwell Direct: What keeps 70+ clients from leaving
A direct contracting business that employers and unions keep
Happy Tuesday Hospitalogists,
Here’s a detail I haven’t stopped thinking about since recording with Nick Stefanizzi: the CEO of Northwell Direct negotiates reimbursement rates with his own parent company. Think about the org design it takes to make that possible, and why it might be the reason employers trust the model.
Today’s breakdown is the full story on how Northwell built Direct and what the system gets out of it.
Enjoy!
BLAKE’S BREAKDOWN
Northwell Direct Runs Direct Contracting Like a Business, Not a PilotCopy anchor linkCopied
Back in July, I shared a handful of takeaways from my conversations with Nick Stefanizzi, CEO of Northwell Direct: how the 32BJ deal came together, the pricing stack behind it, and why Northwell refuses to become an insurance company. But there was so much more to break down from our full Claims Denied episode that I didn’t want to stop there. Consider this the sequel, built around the questions that issue left open. How do you structure a health system so direct contracting doesn’t die as a side project? What’s in it for the system? And how are the carriers reacting?
Key takeaways
- Northwell Direct is a wholly owned but autonomous business, and its CEO negotiates rates against his own parent company because Direct is firewalled from managed care.
- The insurance back office is rented, not built, and the partnerships are deliberately non-exclusive.
- Retention is 97% over four years, and the only departures were acquisitions and clients dropping below New York’s self-funding threshold.
- Northwell’s payoff is mission first, market share second, and growth third.
- Anthem wraps the network with national coverage, and Nick’s explanation of why is worth reading closely.
The accidental benefits CEOCopy anchor linkCopied
Nick has spent 17 years in the Northwell family, and none of them in traditional managed care. He started in technology as chief of staff to the system’s CIO (he was the guy raising his hand in every meeting to ask what the acronym meant). From there he moved through ambulatory shared services and clinical joint ventures in urgent care, ambulatory surgery, and dialysis, then human resources. In 2016 he joined the founding team of a revenue cycle and patient access startup that Northwell built with a private equity partner, where he was chief administrative officer. He calls it his “kitchen sink” role: everything the CEO couldn’t convince anyone else to take. In 2020, he was asked to lead Northwell Direct.
Nick’s own framing is that he isn’t a traditional managed care guy, and I think that’s the point. Northwell picked an operator who knew the organization, had relationships across it, and had built businesses in white space, not a payor veteran. The HR chapter mattered too. It gave him benefits exposure and an appreciation for culture and org structure, which he says he leans on as a CEO. When health systems ask how to get started, I’ll be asking who they’re putting in charge before I ask about vendors.
Not a side-desk projectCopy anchor linkCopied
In July I suggested systems consider an autonomous direct-to-employer arm. Nick got much more specific about what that looks like, and about why Northwell got into the fight at all.
Northwell is the largest health system in New York and, by Nick’s account, the state’s largest private employer. It has long treated factors that influence health, from gun violence to food insecurity, as part of its job. Affordability, in his view, belongs on that list. The design question was how to act on it without loading a not-for-profit already under financial pressure with a pile of risk.
The answer was three early decisions. The second, not becoming an insurance company, is the one I covered in July. The other two are the ones I’d put on a whiteboard: run Northwell Direct as a real business, and only build what you’re demonstrably good at. It’s wholly owned by the health system but autonomous, governed by a board that includes health system executives, and run with the discipline that comes with that. Nick says most peers hand direct contracting to someone in managed care or population health as an additional duty. He was diplomatic about it. I’ll be less so: that’s how you end up with a pilot that never graduates.
The firewall is real, too. Because Direct is walled off from Northwell’s managed care function, Nick negotiates reimbursement rates with his own parent company. Imagine sitting across the table from the organization you belong to. I’d argue that detail does more to make the model credible to a union trustee than any slide on governance.
Anchor tenant, rented back officeCopy anchor linkCopied
According to Nick, the Northwell Direct network spans more than 50 hospitals and 42,000 physicians because other providers opted in. They wanted a piece of the affordability mission and the commercial volume that comes with it. So Direct isn’t selling Northwell exclusivity. It’s selling a high-performance regional network with Northwell as the anchor tenant.
Everything that looks like an insurance company got rented instead of built. Claims processing, utilization management, customer service, ID cards: Nick’s view is that none of it is core to a provider’s DNA, it would have cost a fortune and taken forever, and he wasn’t sure Northwell could build it as well as the independent TPAs who do it all day. His team ran a comprehensive market evaluation and partnered. I mentioned in July that TPAs handle the plumbing. The names are Point C, Wellnet, IBA, and Personify.
What I found most interesting is that those relationships are deliberately non-exclusive. The team wanted the flexibility to curate a package tailored to each employer or union, and Nick says they’ve learned a ton from every partner along the way. It’s a procurement strategy disguised as an operating model, and it keeps the system from locking itself into one vendor’s blind spots.
Retention is the tellCopy anchor linkCopied
First customers went live July 1, 2022. Nick says the platform now serves 70+ local, regional, and national employers and unions, covering more than 300,000 members in the New York metro and roughly $2.5 billion in medical spend. Cumulative client savings sit above $150 million over four years. But the stat I keep coming back to is 97% retention over the same period.
The handful that left did so for two reasons: they were acquired by larger companies that rolled them onto their own benefits, or they fell below New York’s 100-employee threshold for self-funded plans. Nick’s logic is blunt. Affordability is the entire reason clients opt in, so if Direct jacked up rates in year two, they’d walk. Retention imposes a cost discipline that no press release can.
It also shows what “direct” means in practice. Nick’s team sits down with every client month to month to review how the product is performing, whether they’re seeing the value, and where the data points to new clinical interventions. I discount most vendor-reported metrics. Retention is harder to spin.
Weekly reps at the union hallCopy anchor linkCopied
In July I told you the 32BJ deal closed in 75 days. Here’s how the sausage got made.
Nick and 32BJ were introduced in August 2025, and he hosted them for the first meeting at Northwell’s Greenwich Village hospital. It opened as a freestanding emergency department and has since added diagnostic services, physician offices, and an inpatient unit. The building, it turns out, is the old Maritime Union Hall. I called it ironic in real time, and I stand by that. Nick’s read was that both sides were ready, strategically and culturally, and that Northwell had built something different from competing systems: dedicated infrastructure capable of delivering at scale.
What followed was a weekly cadence: a meeting, clear deliverables, and then another meeting where both sides delivered what they’d promised. Trust compounded week over week. The third-party repricing I flagged in July put a number on it, 20% savings or $46 million in year one based on the fund’s own historical utilization, and the two sides shook hands in mid-October. They went live in April 2026. Nick also said the discipline, creativity, and sophistication he saw at 32BJ is something he hasn’t seen matched in many employers or unions, so the buyer set a high bar. If you’re a system leader, steal the cadence: a sales cycle that runs like a project plan.
Boring is the goalCopy anchor linkCopied
The benefit design numbers are worth knowing. 32BJ cut inpatient copays from $1,000 to $100 and set physician visits with participating providers at $0. Nick stressed the word “encourage”: no one is forced anywhere, but a $0 copay moves behavior on its own. 32BJ projects its members will save about $5 million in copays on top of the fund’s savings, and Nick says similar designs show up at other clients. Care management adds the long game, with programs around diabetes, chronic kidney disease, and transitional care that turn better outcomes into dollars over time.
Then there’s go-live. About three months in, at the time of recording, the first executive steering committee had just met, and Nick reported the most boring news possible: correct copays at the point of care, claims flowing, communications landing, and education happening on both the provider and member side. His team even used technology as belt and suspenders at the front desk to help staff assess the right copay. In benefits operations, boring is a compliment. Strategy decks tend to skip this part, so I appreciated that Nick didn’t.
What Northwell getsCopy anchor linkCopied
With trend guarantees flowing to clients, I pushed Nick on the other side of the ledger: where does Northwell make it back? He didn’t dodge. Competition for share in the New York metro is fierce, and Direct positions the system to win a bigger share of utilization within a given population, without forcing a choice on anyone. Clients with a couple of years of tenure, which is most of them, already show a growing share of members choosing Northwell providers. He didn’t share the size of that shift, which I’d love to see eventually. The margin gets invested back into the clinical enterprise.
His stack ranking is mission first, market share second, and growth of the broader organization third. You can quibble with the order, but it’s hard to quibble with the honesty. This is a volume-for-price trade, and it only works if the share shift is real and sustained. Nobody in a competitive market does this out of charity, and Nick didn’t pretend otherwise.
The fraternityCopy anchor linkCopied
In July I told health system leaders to start experimenting today. Nick gave me the how. He spends a lot of time talking to systems about this, and he’s passionate about it because the more of them that do it, the less scary it looks. His advice is two steps. First, start with a conversation with an employer or union in your market, because they’ll give you the insights you need. Second, pick one thing, start there, and find partners to wrap around you.
He pointed to Orlando Health, which started with Disney, along with Henry Ford, Providence, and Baylor Scott & White. Everybody is doing it a little differently, and he hasn’t found another Northwell Direct. Because they aren’t competing for the same markets, they share best practices like a fraternity. To the bear case, that this is a fad that only works with critical mass, he gave three answers: look at the results, look at the breadth of interest (nearly every system he talks to is thinking about it), and accept that the current cost trajectory isn’t sustainable.
The carrier wrapCopy anchor linkCopied
I asked what happens to managed care if this keeps growing, and Nick opened with a caveat that he isn’t a managed care expert. Then he declined the easy answer. Cutting out the middleman would sound snappy, he said, but it’s overly simplistic. National carriers still have a role: wrapping Direct’s local high-performance network with their national network means members keep local choice and get coverage beyond where Direct reaches. Those relationships will look different, he said, but they won’t disappear.
Anthem is his example in New York. He gave three reasons a national carrier plays ball: it’s a chance to win new business, it’s a retention tool for existing customers, and Anthem recognized that the train on direct contracting had left the station. It was better to be part of the solution than to fight it.
What’s nextCopy anchor linkCopied
Nick couldn’t name names, but he teased significant announcements heading into the January 1 renewal cycle, with additional sizable unions and employer groups. He credits the 32BJ relationship and his team’s investment in the broker and labor communities for the momentum.
Direct contracting spent years as a panel topic. Nick’s version has 70+ clients and 97% retention. He’s agreed to come back once the logos drop. I’m going to hold him to that.
THE PROVIDER-PATIENT RELATIONSHIP IS INCREASINGLY WON BETWEEN VISITS.
No wonder the share of healthcare executives calling AI clinical tools their top tech priority has tripled in just 3 years.
On Dec. 8, join me, Dr. Jim Geracci and Doug Rogers for a look at how AI care team members like Tom are helping health systems build stronger connections in primary care, which tasks stay with nurses and physicians, and the metrics worth tracking.
Bring your predictions for AI in primary care and we’ll bring ours!
ON YOUR RADAR
- Health systems aren’t short on data. They’re short on follow-through. NRC Health’s new report shows what high performers do differently once the insights arrive. Read the findings.*
- New podcast dropped: The Neonatologist Who Wants Fewer NICU Beds, with Dr. Ross Sommers, CEO and Founder of Firstday Healthcare.
- At least 11 health insurers have filed lawsuits against CMS over their 2027 MA star ratings: Becker’s Payer Issues.
- CommonSpirit posts $544 million operating loss: Modern Healthcare.
- Lumeris announced the launch of a new company, Tom Health.
- Judy Faulkner’s leadership rules, in her own words: Becker’s Health IT.
- 5 midterm takeaways for healthcare leaders: Becker’s Hospital Review.
*This read is brought to you by one of my brand partners who help make this newsletter possible!
Thanks for the read! Let me know what you thought by replying back to this email.
— Blake

